Severance Agreements in New York: Why Employers Should Offer Them, What They Must Contain, and Where Employers Go Wrong
Status note: New York’s legislature passed the No Severance Ultimatums Act on June 1, 2026. If it is signed by the Governor, it takes effect immediately and requires every New York employer to give a departing employee at least 21 days to consider a severance agreement that includes a release, plus 7 days to revoke it, regardless of the employee’s age. Employers that build their agreements to that standard now will not need to rework their templates later. This article explains why severance agreements remain one of the most useful tools an employer has at termination, what a compliant agreement must contain today, and how to prepare for the new law.
Terminating an employee is the moment an employer is most exposed to a claim. The employee has lost income, may have a grievance, and has the time and motivation to consult a lawyer. New York is an at-will employment state, but at-will status does not protect an employer from claims of discrimination, retaliation, unpaid wages, or breach of an express or implied promise. A well-drafted severance agreement is the ordinary way to convert that open-ended exposure into a fixed and known cost.
The agreement is also a legal instrument with strict formal requirements. Federal law, New York law, and now a pending New York statute each impose conditions on whether a release will be enforced. An employer that pays severance under a defective agreement can end up having paid for a release that does not hold.
Severance Is Not Required, But It Is Usually Worth Paying For
No New York or federal statute requires a private employer to pay severance. An obligation arises, if at all, from an employment contract, an offer letter, a written policy, an established past practice, or an ERISA-governed severance plan. Before deciding what to offer, an employer should confirm whether any of those sources already promises severance, because an amount the employee is already entitled to receive cannot serve as consideration for a release.
The bargain is simple. The employee receives something of value beyond what is already owed. The employer receives a release of claims and, usually, a set of continuing obligations. Both sides get certainty, and the employer avoids the cost, distraction, and publicity of litigation that may have little merit but would still be expensive to defend.
What a Release Actually Buys the Employer
A properly drafted release extinguishes the employee’s known and unknown claims through the date of signing. In an employment setting, that typically includes claims under Title VII, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, the Americans with Disabilities Act, and the Family and Medical Leave Act, as well as claims under the New York State Human Rights Law, the New York City Human Rights Law, the retaliation provisions of the New York Labor Law, and common-law contract and tort theories.
Small employers should not assume they fall outside these laws. The New York State Human Rights Law applies to employers of every size, regardless of the number of employees.
Time matters as well. Without a release, an employee’s claims remain open for years. A discrimination claim under the State or City Human Rights Law can generally be brought within three years, and wage claims under the Labor Law carry a six-year limitations period. A release closes that window on the day it becomes effective.
A release does have limits, and an employer should not describe it as a complete shield. An employee cannot waive the right to file an administrative charge or take part in an agency investigation, although the agreement can waive the right to individual monetary recovery from such a charge. Workers’ compensation benefits, unemployment insurance benefits, and vested benefits are not releasable. And courts in the Second Circuit have required judicial or Department of Labor approval before a Fair Labor Standards Act settlement is enforceable. See Cheeks v. Freeport Pancake House, Inc., 796 F.3d 199 (2d Cir. 2015). An employer should therefore never treat a release as a substitute for paying all wages that are actually owed.
Beyond the release itself, the agreement gives the employer an opportunity to secure other protections: return of company property, protection of confidential information, cooperation in transition and pending matters, and reaffirmation of any enforceable restrictive covenants. On that last point, see our discussion of New York non-compete law in 2026.
The Core Terms of a New York Severance Agreement
Every agreement should be tailored to the employee and the circumstances, but a New York agreement should address the following at a minimum:
- Consideration. Something of value beyond any amount already owed, stated clearly, with payment conditioned on the release becoming effective.
- A specific general release. Broad in scope, but naming the statutes being released, covering claims through the date of signing, and excluding future claims.
- Carve-outs for rights that cannot be waived. Vested benefits, unemployment and workers’ compensation benefits, indemnification rights, and any claim that cannot lawfully be released.
- Protected-activity language. A statement that nothing in the agreement prevents the employee from filing a charge, communicating with a government agency, testifying, exercising rights under Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act, or reporting possible securities violations to the SEC. See 17 C.F.R. § 240.21F-17.
- Continuing obligations. Protection of trade secrets and confidential business information, return of property, cooperation, and any restrictive covenants the employer intends to preserve.
- A knowing and voluntary acknowledgment. Written advice to consult an attorney, the consideration and revocation periods, and a clearly stated effective date.
- Standard protective provisions. No admission of liability, integration, severability, governing law, and venue.
- Tax and timing provisions. Withholding, and payment terms structured to comply with, or be exempt from, Section 409A of the Internal Revenue Code.
Federal Requirements: The Older Workers Benefit Protection Act
For any employee age 40 or older, a release of age discrimination claims is enforceable only if it satisfies the Older Workers Benefit Protection Act, codified at 29 U.S.C. § 626(f). The statute requires that the agreement be written in plain language, refer specifically to rights under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act, not waive claims arising after signing, be supported by additional consideration, and advise the employee in writing to consult an attorney. The employee must be given at least 21 days to consider the agreement and 7 days after signing to revoke it, and the agreement does not become effective until the revocation period ends.
In a group termination or exit incentive program, the consideration period extends to 45 days, and the employer must provide written disclosures at the start of that period identifying the class, unit, or group covered, the eligibility factors and time limits, and the job titles and ages of all individuals selected and not selected. EEOC regulations also provide that a material change to the final offer restarts the consideration period unless the parties agree otherwise. 29 C.F.R. § 1625.22(e)(4).
The consequences of noncompliance are severe. The employer bears the burden of proving that the waiver was knowing and voluntary and met every statutory requirement. 29 U.S.C. § 626(f)(3). In Oubre v. Entergy Operations, Inc., 522 U.S. 422 (1998), the Supreme Court held that a release that does not comply with the statute cannot bar an age discrimination claim, that the employee is not required to return the severance payment before suing, and that keeping the payment does not ratify the release. The employer pays the severance and still faces the claim.
New York Requirements: General Obligations Law Section 5-336
New York layers its own rules onto agreements that resolve claims of discrimination, harassment, or retaliation. Under General Obligations Law § 5-336, as amended effective November 17, 2023, an employer may not include a nondisclosure provision that would prevent disclosure of the underlying facts and circumstances of such a claim unless confidentiality is the complainant’s preference. Where it is, the complainant must be given 21 days to consider the agreement, which the complainant may choose to shorten by signing earlier, and 7 days to revoke after signing. The 2023 amendment extended the statute beyond discrimination to harassment and retaliation claims, and extended its protection to independent contractors.
The amendment also created a rule that affects nearly every separation agreement drafted for a New York employee. A release of any claim whose factual foundation involves discrimination, harassment, or retaliation is unenforceable if the agreement requires the employee to pay liquidated damages for violating a nondisclosure or non-disparagement provision, requires the employee to forfeit all or part of the consideration for such a violation, or requires the employee to affirmatively state that he or she was not subjected to discrimination, harassment, or retaliation. Many form agreements contain all three. An agreement that includes confidentiality terms must also preserve the employee’s right to speak with law enforcement, the EEOC, the New York State Division of Human Rights, local human rights commissions, the Attorney General, and the employee’s own attorney.
Because an employer rarely knows with certainty that a departing employee has no potential claim of this kind, the practical course is to draft every New York separation agreement to the Section 5-336 standard. The statute is available from the New York State Senate.
The No Severance Ultimatums Act: Pending, and Worth Preparing For
The No Severance Ultimatums Act, Senate Bill S372A with Assembly companion A6480A, would add a new Section 215-d to the Labor Law. It applies to any agreement an employer offers upon separation, related to the separation, that requires the employee to release waivable claims. An employer offering such an agreement would have to notify the employee of the right to consult an attorney, provide at least 21 calendar days to consider the agreement, and allow 7 calendar days after signing to revoke it, with the agreement not effective until the revocation period expires.
The employee may sign before the 21 days run, but only if the decision is knowing and voluntary and is not induced by fraud, misrepresentation, a threat to withdraw or change the offer before the period ends, or an offer of different terms to employees who sign early. An agreement that violates these requirements is void and unenforceable. The only waiver available is through a severance agreement negotiated under a collective bargaining agreement that specifically acknowledges the section.
The reach of the Act is what makes it significant. The Older Workers Benefit Protection Act protects only employees age 40 and older, and Section 5-336 reaches only agreements involving discrimination, harassment, or retaliation claims. The Act would cover every employee, of any age, and every severance agreement that contains a release. The sponsor’s memorandum states that the purpose is to extend the protections of the federal statute to all New York employees.
As to status, the Senate passed the bill on February 11, 2026, and the Assembly passed it on June 1, 2026. The bill provides that it takes effect immediately upon signature. As of the date of this article, the Senate’s official bill page lists the bill as passed by both houses and does not show that it has been delivered to the Governor or signed. Some commentary has described the bill as enacted, so employers should confirm the current status before relying on either position. The Governor may sign the bill, veto it, or seek amendments.
Because a noncompliant agreement would be void with no grace period, the safer course is to adopt the 21-day and 7-day framework now. The cost to the employer is a few weeks before the agreement becomes effective. The benefit is avoiding the risk of paying severance under an agreement that proves unenforceable.
Confidentiality and Non-Disparagement: The NLRA Problem
Employers often want a severance agreement to keep the terms confidential and to bar the employee from criticizing the company. For employees covered by the National Labor Relations Act, which includes non-supervisory employees whether or not they are unionized, those provisions carry federal risk. In McLaren Macomb, 372 NLRB No. 58 (2023), the Board held that merely offering a severance agreement containing broad confidentiality or non-disparagement terms violates Section 8(a)(1) of the Act, because such terms tend to interfere with employees’ Section 7 rights.
That decision remains Board law. The Board’s General Counsel has since urged the Board to overrule it, and an administrative law judge applied it as recently as May 2026, but until the Board acts, employers should draft with it in mind. Confidentiality clauses should be limited to genuine trade secrets and proprietary business information. Non-disparagement clauses should be narrowly defined. And the agreement should include a clear statement that nothing in it restricts activity protected by Section 7.
Wages, Taxes, and Reductions in Force
Severance does not replace what is already owed. Under Labor Law § 191(3), a terminated employee must be paid all earned wages no later than the next regular payday, and Labor Law § 193 restricts deductions from wages. Labor Law § 195(6) separately requires the employer to give a terminated employee written notice of the exact date of termination and the exact date benefits are cancelled, within five working days of termination. A severance agreement should not be used to delay, offset, or condition any of these obligations.
Severance is also taxable wages, subject to income tax withholding and payroll taxes. Installment payments must be structured to comply with, or fall within an exception to, Section 409A of the Internal Revenue Code. And under Section 162(q), an employer may not deduct a settlement or payment related to sexual harassment or sexual abuse if it is subject to a nondisclosure agreement, which is another reason to avoid confidentiality terms concerning the underlying facts.
When several employees are separated at once, additional rules apply. The group disclosure requirements of the Older Workers Benefit Protection Act apply, and the employer must also evaluate the federal WARN Act and the New York WARN Act, which requires 90 days’ notice for covered employers. Severance is not a substitute for required notice.
Common Mistakes
- Paying first and papering later. Severance paid without a signed release, or before the revocation period ends, leaves the employer with nothing to show for the payment.
- Using a generic or out-of-state template. Forms that ignore Section 5-336, the Labor Law notice requirements, or the OWBPA conditions can render the release unenforceable.
- Pressure tactics. Exploding offers and artificially short deadlines invite challenges to whether the employee signed knowingly and voluntarily, and are exactly what the pending Act targets.
- Missing group disclosures. In a reduction in force, omitting the decisional unit and age data required for employees over 40 invalidates the age claim waiver.
- Overbroad confidentiality and non-disparagement terms. These create exposure under both the NLRA and Section 5-336.
- Overlooking final pay and notices. Failing to pay earned wages on time or to provide the Labor Law § 195(6) notice creates separate liability regardless of the release.
- Inconsistent treatment. Offering materially different terms to similarly situated employees can itself become evidence in a later discrimination claim.
- Ignoring a known problem. Offering a release to an employee who has already complained, requested an accommodation, or taken protected leave requires particular care, and it does not repair a termination that was poorly documented.
A Practical Sequence for Employers
A disciplined process reduces risk more than any single clause. Employers should consider the following sequence:
- Review existing obligations. Check employment contracts, offer letters, policies, and any severance plan for promised benefits and release conditions.
- Assess the risk. Consider the employee’s age, protected characteristics, recent complaints, leave or accommodation history, and any whistleblowing activity.
- Calibrate the offer. Severance is commonly scaled to length of service, seniority, and the level of risk, applied consistently across similarly situated employees.
- Pay what is owed on time. Final wages and the required written notices are separate from severance and cannot wait on the agreement.
- Deliver the agreement in writing. Include the right to consult an attorney, the consideration period, the revocation period, and any group disclosures.
- Pay only after the agreement is effective. Make payment after the revocation period expires, and keep the signed agreement and delivery records.
A severance agreement will not cure a termination decision that was itself unlawful, and it is not necessary in every situation. But for most New York employers, it is the most reliable way to end the employment relationship on defined terms. As the legal framework moves toward longer review periods and stricter formalities, the employers best positioned are those that have already updated their process.
Planning a Termination or Updating Your Separation Agreement Template?
Parandian Law advises employers throughout Westchester County and the greater New York area on terminations, separation agreements, restrictive covenants, and employment compliance. We can review your current template against New York’s existing requirements and the pending changes, or prepare an agreement for a specific separation.
Click the link below to schedule a consultation or feel contact us at (914) 793-2626. Our office is located at 245 Main Street, Suite 610, White Plains, NY 10601.
